Imagine a carpenter

A quite competent carpenter.

Just fine at understanding plans, working efficiently and accurately, and adding nice touches to her projects—touches that may sometimes be more subtle than what a non-carpenter might notice, but which give her great satisfaction.

She has spent her career for the most part working to plan, on projects commissioned by and designed for others. She has given good value, and the people who hire her once are very likely to call her for their subsequent projects. She has every reason to think of herself as a good carpenter. With each passing year, she feels a little better at it.

Nonetheless, she has never been able to shake the feeling that she wants to build… something else. She is proud of her craft, proud that her clients value her work. But being valued for her contributions to other people’s projects increasingly feels like… not enough.

She feels—has always felt—a desire to build something that feels like her, something that she can sign her name to and that will tell people who she really is. She knows, in other words, that there is a difference between being good at the specific tasks of her craft and using that craft to build something that is uniquely hers, something that no one else could have built

* * * * *

This is how I feel about my writing. Seemingly my whole life, I’ve been told—first by teachers, then professors, colleagues, and clients—I’m “good at” writing. I make a good living from it—well, a good enough living.

The good living, and the being good at writing, all mean nothing, of course.

They do not scratch the itch.

Somewhere I read a quote I cannot now locate that goes something like this:

You must write many books before you write the one you can sign your name to.

I am 44, and it feels as though I’ve been doing something like the first part of this quote for most of my life at this point. I actually haven’t written any “books,” but I’ve filled dozens or maybe even a hundred notebooks, I’ve kept blogs, I’ve published a little journalism, I’ve explored in so many directions. And I’ve let myself off the hook again and again.

For the last year, I’ve experienced something of a creative awakening. A greater level of commitment to at least practicing my writing. Up every morning at 0430 so I can get in a couple of hours every morning. This practice and the flow I experienced was initially unlocked in the fall of November 2017 by what I experienced as the suspenseful banality or maybe the banal suspense of Karl Ove Knausgaard’s My Struggle.

For much of this last year, I tried to write like him. It was the first time time that I had engaged in personal writing projects that were sustained over weeks and months. But I ended up abandoning everything I wrote last year, or at least putting it aside. Who knows, perhaps I will discover something there later on.

In my fascination with Knausgaard—a horrified fascination, at times, to be sure—I discovered in myself a desire to find a way to process life in writing, more or less as it happens. Although blogging might seem a natural way to do this at first glance, early last year I decided I had abandoned blogging forever.

Perhaps I was aping the way KOK (as I abbreviate Knausgaard’s name in my journal) seemed to cut himself off from the world, to care not a whit for what the world thought of him or how his writing affected others.

Certainly this way of working strikes me as brave, and, for KOK, clearly essential—and I could readily see how, in my past blogging, I had at times been hampered too much by thinking ahead to how what I was writing might affect or be received by my audience.

So I plugged along, in private, helping my words to flow and myself to be utterly honest by telling myself over and over that I didn’t know or even care if any of it were ever published.

Suddenly, a few days ago, something changed. There are too many inputs to that change to list here or even identify for myself. But something of the sentiment can be found in, of all things, an Austin Kleon blog post from about a week ago, reflecting on why he has produced the particular body of work that he has.

All I ever wanted to do was be part of the world I loved. The world I discovered in books and art and music. I want to be part of it. I don’t care how or in what capacity.

What’s the point, here? Why do I even write books in the first place?

It’s just to join in the fun. To be part of that world that I love. To be in a chain that goes backwards and forwards, no matter how puny my link.

Nathaniel Hawthorne said in his 1851 preface to his Twice-Told Tales, that they were “not the talk of a secluded man with his own mind and heart… but his attempts, and very imperfectly successful ones, to open an intercourse with the world.”

That’s it.

That’s what I want.

I do, after all, want an “intercourse with the world” via writing (and via photography and podcasting). I want to run a blog that is, itself, something of a work of art, a rendering of my experience with the world.

Even in the few days since I’ve had this idea, I have felt something happening to the way I look at the world, I have felt yet another unlocking of some part of my creative self.

I want to engage with the world in writing. No time like the present, and why not every day.

My goal is to exceed your expectations

Back at the hotel, around 0515, as I was throwing things back into my bag and preparing to decamp for Starbucks, I had decided to have a second cup of coffee.

The room featured one of the little one-cup brewers you see everywhere now. You tear open a little packet containing a disposable plastic tray and a tissue-papery pouch of grounds. The tray slots into place on the coffee machine, and you pour enough water for one cup into an opening on top, put your cup in place, and press a little silver button to start it brewing.

I grabbed one of the three remaining packets. Decaf, which I don’t mind later in the day but wasn’t what I was after now. I flipped through the remaining two and discovered my room had apparently been stocked with three packets of decaf and only one of regular. For a second the thought jumped to mind that that made it okay that I’d forgotten to bring cash for a tip, but of course it didn’t.

It had snowed the night before, just enough to coat the car under a half-inch of white, but the parking lots were clear and wet, no doubt percolating under some sprinkling of anti-snow poison. I started the car warming with my spare key, walked back into the lobby to get the luggage cart, and loaded all of my bags onto it in the room.

No formal checking out is ever required anymore, at least not from the hotel’s standpoint, they have your credit card information, they’ll get their money. But it feels weird to me to just leave the key cards in the room and walk out without saying goodbye.

I parked the luggage cart by the side door leading from my hallway out into the parking and walked back to the lobby.

There was no one at the counter, but I could see a sliver of a man’s oxford-shirted shoulders back in the office. I ahem-ed, and immediately regretted bothering him. He was up like a shot and hurried out to the counter, his hands together in a supplicatory posture in front of his chest, and actually apologizing for “making you wait.”

This excruciating awareness we carry around of how vulnerable, how expendable everyone is these days.

My mind went back to the laminated letter I’d found waiting in my room after I’d checked in the night before. It was from a man named Potts, the hotel’s general manager, the man—the letter informed me—who is “directly responsible for the room [I] have been given.”

It went on, in a tone I found uncomfortably abject:

“My goal is to exceed your expectations. If you feel that this is not the case or if there is anything I can do to make your experience her [sic] more enjoyable please contact me immediately, so I may have an opportunity to correct the problem and address any concerns.”

About a year ago, as I’d been checking into a different hotel, the manager had tried to hand me a chocolate chip cookie. According to a little plastic placard standing on the counter, which alleged that the cookie was “fresh-baked,” this was a standard Hilton practice at check-in. If it happened that I weren’t offered a cookie, I was apparently supposed to get some sort of discount. After I had demurred, the manager went on to make some similar points to those in Mr. Potts’s letter but ended with the direct request that—if there turned out to be anything I didn’t enjoy about my stay—I should tell him directly and not “write a bad review on Yelp.”

Mr. Potts’s letter didn’t mention online reviews explicitly, but I felt his terror of them emanating through the letter’s protective layer of plastic. As it happened, in the course of the evening, I did find myself somewhat unsatisfied with the hotel, namely because of two fruitless trips to the little alcove next to the front desk where snacks and beverages were arrayed for sale.

On the first trip, I was after almonds, which I’m almost always triggered to eat when I travel, especially when I’ve reached the discomfiting plastic environs of yet another hotel and feel the blank isolating anonymity pressing in on me. No almonds, so I went back to my room empty-handed.

Then, a little later, it occurred to me that some gum or mints might be just the thing, but after I’d walked all the way back down to the lobby again they turned out not to have any of those, either.

I went back to my room and made do with two hard-boiled eggs left over from the lunch I’d brought along in a little cooler. As I peeled and ate them with a little of the salt I carry with me in my possibles bag, I imagined being the kind of person who would contact Mr. Potts and ask him to “address” his lobby shop’s lack of non-legume-based protein and/or means of breath-freshening.

The strategy that came to mind was to mention the ennui and existential despair that had come over me as I’d walked up the long, empty, dimly-lit hallway toward my room, transfixed by the dizzying, amoeba-like patterns worked into the carpet, but then to let him off the hook by saying I’d forgive it all if he could run to the store and bring me a tin of Altoids, preferably the invigorating and life-affirming cinnamon-flavored variety.

I enjoyed imagining this phone call as I undressed, got into bed, and hoisted the immense weight of volume 6 of Knausgaard’s My Struggle onto my belly.

But back to checkout. I had handed the clerk my key cards and, thinking we were done, was already turning away, my mind on my unattended luggage at the end of the hall.

“Want to sell your hat?”

“What?” It had been off script, unexpected, so at first I didn’t understand what he’d said.

“Want to sell your hat?” he repeated, with the slight awkwardness of someone repeating a joke. “That’s a great hat.”

“Oh,” I mumbled. “Uh…thanks!”

“Have a great trip!” he said, with a great big cheerful smile.

“You, too!” I replied, trying to match his cheerfulness, not noticing what I’d said until I’d turned away and started down the hall toward the luggage cart.

You, too?

Well… How did I get here?

“Maybe I’m fascinated with the middle class because it seems so different from my life, so distant from what I do. I can’t imagine living like that.”

David Byrne

I’m not living in a shotgun shack, but I am living in another part of the world.

Elkins, West Virginia is just a few hours’ drive from the city of my birth but mere driving time doesn’t paint an accurate picture of the real distance between the two places. Elkins couldn’t be more different from that place, from Miami, Seattle, New York, Berlin, Istanbul—all of the big international cities where I either lived or at one point in life would have considered it entirely likely that I would end up.

Instead here I am, a settled burgher who has now lived in this little speck of a place longer than any other spot on earth. A homeowner, a member of the local planning commission, the president of the board of a local do-gooding organization. The former city clerk.

Beautiful wife (and kids). Large automobile. My parents up on the hill, a five-minute walk away.

“We’re largely unconscious,” David Byrne told NPR in 2000. “You know, we operate half awake or on autopilot and end up, whatever, with a house and family and job and everything else.”

The twentysomething version of myself would have been shocked to learn how it has turned out by this point—shocked, and, dare I say, disappointed, perhaps even paralyzed by dread. I cannot express enough how opposed I once was to this kind of life.

What would really shock that earlier version of me is how much I have come to love it—this life, this strange little town.

I think it’s a mistake to compare how our lives have turned out to how the twenty-something version of ourselves would have wanted. That’s when we knew the least, that’s when we were trying on beliefs like shirts we couldn’t afford, turning this way and that in the mirror, imagining what if.

From the moment I first heard “Once in a Lifetime,” I suspected it had something important to tell me. Back then it was a prospective message—in fact, the way the song is worded suggests it is being spoken by an older person to a younger one. The cascade of lines beginning with “you may…” evoked the wide-open possibilities of the future.

I heard a note of warning. At the age of, say, 16 or 18 or 21 I certainly had no use for the idea of beautiful houses or large automobiles or any of the other well-chosen totems of a square, settled, middle-class existence. But that was all right, the song also held out the possibility of escape and reinvention.

Into the blue again, after the money’s gone.

I listened to this song most frequently during my four years before the mast, my shock-resistant Discman velcroed to the yellow metal wall of my little coffin-sized bunk as our ship labored through the rough waters of the Bering Sea. I was in my early twenties, I’d left college halfway through, no one back at school would answer my letters, I’d been unlucky in love. My life felt as wide open and unimaginable as the water stretching on all sides to the horizon. I carried around the feeling this song gave me like a sugar cube melting on my tongue.

There is water at the bottom of the ocean.

Like a tightrope walker, sometimes it’s not a good idea to pay too much attention to what you are doing. One second you are striding along confidently, then you look down at your feet and the ground and go all wobbly. What am I doing all the way up here?

How do I work this?

The person I was in my early twenties had a cartoon conception of the writing life. Brooklyn apartment, stubble, cigarettes. Need I say more? For a long time I felt like I shouldn’t write anymore, because I didn’t have the right kind of life to write about. I had let the days go by, I had ended up in the wrong place. It wasn’t that I didn’t love the people I’d ended up with. I just couldn’t love the person I’d turned out to be, the things I’d walked away from, let drop, failed to follow through on.

But words kept bubbling up in me anyway. I realized, I have the life and material that I have. There is nothing stopping me from writing about it.

There is water underground.

That’s the project here. Letting the days go by, finding bits to hold up and brush off and show to you.

Same as it ever was, same as it ever was
Same as it ever was, same as it ever was
Same as it ever was, same as it ever was
Same as it ever was, same as it ever was

Thanks for reading.

If you like any of it, maybe you could share it with a friend.

If I do it at all, I must delay no longer

“[H]ow few of life’s days and hours (and they not by relative value or proportion, but by chance) are ever noted.

“Probably another point too, how we give long preparations for some object, planning and delving and fashioning, and then, when the actual hour for doing arrives, find ourselves still quite unprepared, and tumble the thing together, letting hurry and crudeness tell the story better than fine work.

“At any rate I obey my happy hour’s command, which seems curiously imperative.”

-Walt Whitman, Specimen Days

And we’re off.